Frequently Asked Questions

New to homemade nut butter? It’s a little different from what you’ll find on the grocery store shelf. Most big-brand peanut butters stay thick and never separate because they add hydrogenated oils or palm oil, and often sugar. We don’t. Every butter starts with roasted nuts or seeds. From there, we add the flavor ingredients listed on the jar, and in some butters a little flour made from the same nut (like peanut flour in a peanut butter) for extra body. No added oils, stabilizers, or preservatives go into our base, so our butters are softer and more spreadable, and the natural oil may rise to the top. Give the jar a good stir before you dig in. Like it firmer? A little time in the fridge helps.

Are your products allergy-friendly? All of our products are made in a home kitchen that also handles peanuts, tree nuts, sesame, milk, soy, and wheat. Our seed butters are made on the same equipment as our nut butters, so they aren’t safe for anyone with a nut allergy. See our Allergy Info page for what’s in each flavor.

Why is there oil on top of my jar? That’s natural oil from the nuts rising to the top. We don’t use any additives to prevent oil separation. Stir it back in with a knife or spoon and you’re good to go.

Do I need to refrigerate it? No. Store it in a cool, dark cupboard. The fridge slows oil separation but makes the butter firmer and harder to spread.

What if my jars freeze? No harm done. Nut butter has almost no water, so freezing won’t hurt it; it just gets firm. Let the jar come to room temperature before you open it, so moisture doesn’t form inside, and never run a cold jar under hot water.

What if my jars sit out or get warm? Room temperature is perfect. In warmer spots, the butter gets thinner, more oil may separate, and add-ins like chocolate may melt. Heat won’t make it unsafe, but lots of heat or sun can make the natural oils go stale sooner. Stir well before using, and store it somewhere cool and dark to keep it fresh.

How long does it keep? Check the best-by date on your jar. Every batch is dated, so you’ll always know when it was made.

What’s the heat packet for? Our spicy flavors (Umbrella Market Line, Firebox Pepita, and Spice Route) are mild in the jar. Each comes with a heat packet tied on, so you decide how hot it gets. Start small (a pinch of cayenne, or ΒΌ teaspoon of the others), stir, and taste before adding more.

Can I try before I buy? Yes, at our market booth! Stop by the Goshen or Alton market for samples. Check our event schedule to see where else we’ll pop up.

Smooth or crunchy? Main Line Classic can be ordered smooth or crunchy in our shop; at events, we usually bring it smooth. Most other flavors are smooth, and some have bits of other ingredients stirred in, such as dried fruit or toffee pieces. Email us if you’d like to special order a batch or two of another flavor made crunchy.

Can I reuse the jar? Please do! Our glass jars are made to keep. They’re great for leftovers, spices, overnight oats, or flowers.

Do you have a loyalty program? Stay tuned!

Why can I only order from Illinois? We’re a home-based cottage food business. Illinois law allows us to sell directly to customers within the state only.

Do you take custom or bulk orders? Sure do! Please email us so we can work out the details together. Keep in mind we’re a small operation that makes everything fresh, so please reach out early and give us plenty of notice before any bulk orders are needed.

I have a question that isn’t here. Email us at howdy@offtherailsnutbutter.com or catch us at an event. We love talking nut butter.